If you’re researching semi-auto shotguns, chances are you’ve already come across the 1187 Remington and noticed there are two main versions that come up most often: the Field model and the Premier model. Both belong to the same iconic lineup and share the same mechanical foundation, but they’re far from identical once you look closely.
For hunters, collectors, competitive shooters, or everyday shotgun users, it’s important to know exactly what sets these two apart so you can decide which one suits your needs best. This full comparison breaks down the build quality, finish, recoil management, durability, value, and everyday handling of each version.
Let’s take a deep dive into how the 1187 Remington Field vs. Premier models really stack up.
The Shared Foundation of the 1187 Remington
Before comparing them, it’s worth noting what the two models have in common. Both are built around the same gas-operated system that the 1187 Remington is famous for—smooth cycling, manageable recoil, and reliable performance with a wide range of loads. Whether you shoot birdshot, buckshot, or heavier hunting shells, the platform is built for versatility.
They also share:
The same receiver dimensions
The same semi-auto operating system
The same action design
The same ability to handle 2¾" and 3" shells (depending on barrel configuration)
Because of these shared traits, both the Field and Premier perform well mechanically. The biggest differences come down to materials, design choices, and user experience rather than core functionality.
Build Quality: What Sets the Field and Premier Apart
When comparing the 1187 Remington Field vs. Premier, the most noticeable difference is in the finish and materials.
The Field model is designed as a rugged, no-nonsense working gun. It generally features:
A matte or satin finish
Simpler checkering
Standard wood or synthetic stock, depending on the year
A utilitarian feel focused on durability
The Field model prioritizes reliability and toughness. It’s the shotgun you take out in the rain, mud, brush, and wetlands without worrying too much about cosmetic wear.
Meanwhile, the Premier model steps things up with more refined craftsmanship. It usually includes:
Gloss or polished blue finish
Higher-grade walnut
Sharper, more detailed checkering
A more luxurious aesthetic
The Premier is built to impress. It’s the gun you carry with pride on opening day—everything looks refined, balanced, and a tier above the basic workhorse Field version. While both models function similarly, the Premier simply feels like a more premium shotgun.
Handling Differences Between Field and Premier Models
Handling is where subtle differences start to show. Because the 1187 Remington Premier typically has higher-grade walnut and a glossier finish, it tends to feel smoother and slightly more balanced. The wood quality can influence weight distribution, making the Premier feel a bit livelier in the hands.
The Field model often feels more neutral and slightly more rugged. It's designed to be used in tough environments, so its finish and stock may have a more textured grip that offers utility over refinement.
Both handle well, but the Premier tends to feel more elegant while the Field feels more utilitarian.
Recoil Management: Does One Perform Better?
The 1187 Remington is known for having softer recoil than many semi-auto shotguns because of its gas system. When comparing the Field and Premier, recoil performance is nearly identical. The gas ports, piston system, and overall mechanics remain the same.
Any slight differences come from:
Stock weight
Type of recoil pad
Minor differences in wood density
Still, both models reduce felt recoil well, even with heavier 3" hunting loads. If recoil sensitivity is a major factor for you, both shotguns offer excellent performance across the board.
Durability and Long-Term Reliability
Both versions of the 1187 Remington are durable, but their finishes create different experiences over time.
The Field model’s matte or satin finish holds up against harsh weather and rough environments. Scratches, moisture, and abrasions are less noticeable. It's built for hunters who don’t want to baby their shotgun.
The Premier model, with its glossy finish, is more susceptible to visible wear. You’ll want to take a little more care to avoid scratches, dents, or finish damage. It can absolutely handle rough environments, but most owners tend to treat it more carefully due to its refined appearance.
Mechanically, both models last decades when properly maintained. Parts availability has been strong historically due to widespread popularity.
Aesthetics: Which One Has the Advantage?
The Premier model is the clear winner in visual appeal. Its fine walnut, polished finish, and detailed checkering make it a standout piece, often used by collectors or shooters who appreciate craftsmanship.
The Field model has a simpler, more rugged look—less shine, more durability. It appeals to hunters who want reliable performance without worrying about cosmetic wear.
Neither is “better” aesthetically; they simply cater to different preferences.
Use Case: Which Shotgun Fits Your Needs Best?
Choosing between the Field and Premier versions of the 1187 Remington largely depends on how and where you shoot.
The Field model is best for:
Waterfowl hunting
Upland hunting
Rugged field conditions
Users who want practicality over looks
Shooters who prioritize durability
The Premier model is ideal for:
Collectors
Shooters who value premium aesthetics
Individuals wanting a refined field gun
Lighter upland hunting
Those who want a more “elegant” shotgun experience
If you regularly hunt in muddy marshes or harsh weather, the Field model is the safer choice. If you enjoy a beautiful, well-made shotgun and want something that feels special every time you carry it, the Premier model shines.
Price and Market Availability
Historically, the Premier model has carried a higher price due to its premium wood and finish. On the used market today, Premier models still tend to fetch more because collectors seek them out.
The Field model often sells for less and is easier to find. It appeals to budget-minded shooters who want a reliable semi-auto without the extra cost of cosmetic upgrades.
Both can be found on the used market, but Premier models are typically absorbed quickly due to their desirability.
If you're looking to buy one today, understanding what constitutes a fair price can depend on wood quality, finish condition, barrel length, and overall mechanical shape.
Final Thoughts
The 1187 Remington Field and Premier models both offer excellent performance, sharing the same smooth gas-operated platform and long-standing reputation for reliability. Your choice comes down to whether you want a rugged working gun or a refined, premium shotgun that stands out in your collection. If you're comparing current listings or trying to find a good deal on either model, checking platforms like GunsAmerica can give you a realistic picture of market value and availability.
